Commentators viewed President Obama’s final State of the Union address as the opening volley of his reelection campaign. Considering the economic state of the country, the speech conveyed an optimistic tone. His theme was for all Americans, the Republican lawmakers specifically, to work together to keep the American Dream alive and save the middle class at the same time. Of course, we are not so naïve to think that any of the Republican’s will cooperate. The Republican’s rebuttal was to reiterate that the country’s condition remains grave.
It was not surprising that Obama’s speech was packed with programs that require the government’s hand to implement. Tactically, he takes the fight to his opposition saying the time for excuses is past and action is needed now. Senator Daniels gave the Republican rebuttal and presented a doom and gloom, pessimistic picture of America’s chances.
Taxes played a big part in the speech. The payroll tax vote still is waiting in the wings, and time is running out to keep the $80 a month in the paychecks of 160 million working Americans. Obama proposed raising taxes on taxpayers earning over $1 million a year. He suggests a 30% tax rate for the wealthiest in the US. The income tax proposal probably hit home for many Americans watching since Republican presidential candidate, Mitt Romney, just released his tax returns. The Romney’s federal income tax rate in 2010 was 13.9%. Their income ranks them among the top tenth of the infamous 1%. The president also proposed doing away with the alternative minimum tax. Imposed in the 60’s, without any cost of living safeguards built into it, this tax was intended to keep the most wealthy with plentiful deductions and tax credits from avoiding income taxes, but now it affects mostly the upper middle class making over $250,000 instead of the millionaires or billionaires, who were the intended target.
Daniels, as the representative of the loyal opposition, agrees that every American should contribute to the recovery. He pointed out it is dumb to raise taxes within a broken tax system, far wiser to eliminate tax breaks and benefits for those that do not need them.
Incentive tax breaks for businesses were Obama’s proposed method for enticing businesses to hire American workers instead of sending needed manufacturing jobs overseas. He proposed doubling tax deductions for manufacturers to make products in the US and providing extra incentives for opening a factory in the struggling rust belt or other communities that lost manufacturing jobs. He intends to take tax breaks away from companies that continue to send jobs outside of the country and impose a minimum tax on all multinational companies that shelter their profits overseas. Those taxes should fund the policy of lowering taxes on the companies that insource jobs and put Americans back to work.
Republicans disagreed with the president’s views on the economy. From where they sit, though he bears no blame for the problems he inherited, his policies made the situation worse. However, their performance is lackluster. Their own poll numbers are plummeting. Though the opposition was careful not to seem disrespectful, Congressional Republicans need to work on their poker faces.
The president offered to work with anyone, but even before the election was on the near horizon, the chances for agreement on anything serious were so small as to be invisible. The list of proposals is an election year gambit. He makes a very public effort to work with Congress. Cynically, we all know it is doomed to fail, but it frees him to accuse the GOP for obstructing his programs and plain doing nothing during the campaign.
